According to Copyscape,
the contents of this section has been stolen by at least ten other web sites, in
violation of copyright law. We urge you to read our web site, instead of those operated
by thieves, because ours is being
continually updated.
How religious conservatives and liberals interpret the Bible:
Since the two groups approach the Bible with different assumptions about its
nature, and look for different content, one can expect that their conclusions
will be very different:
Factor
Typical conservative view
Typical liberal view
The Bible
The Bible was written by authors who
were directly inspired by God. Thus their writings are
seen as inerrant -- completely free of error
as originally written.
The Bible was written
by authors who were intent on promoting their own religious and
spiritual beliefs. The writers lived in a pre-scientific age, which
treated slavery,
genocide, mass murder, and the
oppression of women as
acceptable behaviors.
Bible's authority
The Bible as the actual Word of God and is the prime source of all
religious, spiritual and moral truth. Whenever the
Bible and science disagree, the former must be right.
Since meaningful scientific study of sexual orientation did not begin
until circa 1950 CE, biblical authors had little or no awareness of the topic. When
the Bible and science disagree, we have to give major weighting to the findings of human
sexuality researchers.
Creation stories
They interpret the Garden of Eden story
in the book of Genesis as indicating the fall of humanity into sin.
They view homosexual behavior as one manifestation of that sin.
Conservative theologians typically look for proof texts -- passages that clearly and directly deal with
the topic. These are commonly referred to as the "clobber" passages
described here.
Religious theologians generally look for applicable biblical themes, like those
advocating justice, love, monogamy, caring, commitment, etc.
Basis of truth
"Sola Scriptura" -- solely the Bible.
What the authors of the Bible meant + what church
tradition says + what reason and science tell us + what personal
experience informs us.
God's expectations
Christians should follow the Bible, God's word. It is the source
of absolute truth, is fixed and unchangeable.
Christians should be open to the Holy Spirit teaching
the need for change. This has happened in the past over matters like
slavery and the role of women.
It is happening now over equal rights for those with a
homosexual orientation.
Rigidity of beliefs:
We have exchanged Emails with hundreds of visitors to this web site about the Bible and
homosexuality. Most fall into one of two groups:
Religious liberals promote homosexual ordinations,
same-sex marriage, civil
union ceremonies in the church, equal protection under hate-crime
legislation, protection against discrimination in employment, etc. as fundamental human rights issues.
Religious conservatives feel that the Bible teaches
that homosexual behavior is always a serious sin. Allowing sexually active
gays and lesbians to be ordained, or to have their committed relationships
recognized by the church would involve a drastic and unacceptable lowering of church
standards. The church would be condoning sin. They also oppose including sexual orientation in
hate-crime and
anti-discrimination legislation.
We have been unable to change the beliefs or actions of any of these hundreds
of people on even one point related to homosexuality. Their views appear to
be fixed. It is doubtful that much progress towards compromise on homosexual
rights can be made by means of
dialogue. We don't expect that the attached essays will change the beliefs
of many visitors to this web site. However, the essays may help people
understand opinions that are not their own.
Introduction: Quotations, Overview, Basic approach, A caution, Biblical
references to same-sex Activity, People's beliefs about the Bible. [Please
read this first; otherwise the rest may not make much sense]:
Analysis of key passages from the Hebrew Scriptures (Old Testament):